Which is Better: Mystery Tackle Box or Lucky Tackle Box?

Mystery Tackle Box and Lucky Tackle Box are two companies that make trying out new fishing gear simple with their quick and easy subscription boxes. So which company should you try out this fishing season? Keep reading to find out.


Spring is known for buckets of rain, warmer weather and the beginning of a brand new season with summer just on the horizon. For those with a taste for the water though, spring is the beginning of a season long-awaited: fishing season. Fishing is one of those past times that is passed down from generation to generation and is one of the most exhilarating, yet relaxing, activities you can do in the wake of spring. 


Fishing has long evolved from the traditional hook and worm, however. Nowadays, there are thousands of different types of lures, hooks, and bait. And now, in the age of convenient subscription boxes, trying out the best fishing products is a breeze. So which is best: Lucky Tackle Box or Mystery Tackle Box?


Mystery Tackle Box vs. Lucky Tackle Box




Which is the Best Fishing Subscription Box?


Mystery Tackle Box Things to Know

Mystery Tackle Box is the original monthly lure subscription service that has been operating since 2012. This tackle box subscription provides exactly what their name suggests: a mystery box! Each month, subscribers will receive a custom box based upon several different preferences. All the subscriber needs to do is choose from one of the three box sizes, pick a species and choose a subscription plan.


Mystery Tackle Box offers three different sized boxes: 

  • Regular ($16.99/month)
  • Pro ($26.99/month)
  • Elite ($39.99/month)


All of these Mystery Tackle Box plans offer subscribers to select to a monthly plan, 3-month plan, 6-month plan or 12-month plan. The longer the plan you pick, the more you save per year. Regardless, all plans include free shipping so you can receive your box with any extra fees to worry about.


Use these Mystery Tackle Box coupons to save on your subscription:

Verified
5% Off
Details:

Ongoing Offer

Click "Show Coupon Code" To Activate This Deal. Exclusions May Apply
5% Off Any Subscription
GIVEMTB
Show Code
Verified
$5 Off
Details:

Expires Sep 30th

Click "Show Coupon Code" To Activate This Deal. Exclusions May Apply
$5 Off First Mystery Tackle Box
SAVE5
Show Code


Lucky Tackle Box Things to Know  

Lucky Tackle Box is another monthly subscription service which provides avid anglers and amateur fisherman alike with quality bait, lures and tackle. This subscription service, like the Mystery Tackle Box, comes with options for different species, plans and sizes for their boxes.


Lucky Tackle Box offers three different sized boxes: 

  • Regular ($15.99/month)
  • XL ($21.59/month)
  • Tournament ($36.80/month)


These three box are available as a monthly plan, 3-month plan, 6-month plan or 12-month plan. Similar to the Mystery Tackle Box subscription, you save more if you subscribe to a longer plan with Lucky Tackle Box.


Try pairing a Lucky Tackle Box promo code with your order to save:

Verified
$5 Off
Details:

Ongoing Offer

Click "Show Coupon Code" To Activate This Deal. Exclusions May Apply
$5 Off Your First Box
REFER5
Show Code
Verified
$5 Off
Details:

Expires Dec 31st

Click "Show Coupon Code" To Activate This Deal. Exclusions May Apply
$5 Off Your First Box
SAVE5
Show Code


Mystery Tackle Box and Lucky Tackle Box - Major Differences  

Here are some of the major differences between Mystery Tackle Box and Lucky Tackle Box. These are major factors customers have in mind when making a purchasing decision between Mystery Tackle Box or Lucky Tackle Box.



1. Number of Items in Box

Both Mystery Tackle Box and Lucky Tackle Box offer an assortment of items for fishermen to try out. Mystery Tackle Box offers 5-6, 7-8, or 8-9 items per box (depending on the plan) and Lucky Tackle Box offers a bit more variety at 5, 7, and 13-16 items per box (depending on the plan).

EDGE: Lucky Tackle Box



2. Species Variety

A huge draw for avid fishermen is the ability to be able to catch multiple species for tournaments and recreation alike. Mystery Tackle Box offers 4 different species plus multi-species products while Lucky Tackle Box only offers bass and multi-species.

EDGE: Mystery Tackle Box



3. Value

With either subscription plan, you are going to save money as compared to just opting to pay retail price for each item individually. Mystery Tackle Box values their 3 boxes at $25, $40, and $60 while Lucky Tackle Box values their 3 boxes at $25, $60, and $85+.

EDGE: Lucky Tackle Box



4. Gift Subscriptions

If you don't need a box for yourself but would rather gift a subscription, you can do that with both of these tackle subscription services. You can gift a box from Mystery Tackle Box for $47.97 - $443.88 depending on the box and subscription period (3 months, 6 months, or 12 months). You can gift a box from Lucky Tackle Box for $15.99 - $376.13 depending on the box and subscription period (1 month, 3 months, 6 months, or 12 months).

EDGE: Lucky Tackle Box



5. Online Store

Both subscription services exist alongside online stores from which you can shop for extra tackle. Mystery Tackle Box's online store, Karl's Bait and Tackle, offers an assortment of tackle, rods & reels, accessories, apparel, and more. You even get a discount through any subscription. Lucky Tackle Box also exists alongside their online store which includes items such as gear, baits, lures, rods & reels, accessories, and other bundles. Karl's, overall, seems to have more variety in their store than Lucky.

EDGE: Mystery Tackle Box




Final Mystery Tackle Box vs. Lucky Tackle Box Review

There are many factors to consider when choosing a tackle box subscription service. This all depends on the environment in which you are fishing, the types of species you like to fish, and the variety of products you are seeking to try out. 


The pricing difference between these two services varies slightly, but if you are looking to get more bang for your buck, Lucky Tackle Box is a better choice, especially for the more advanced boxes. However, if you want more variety in your fishing supplies, Mystery Tackle Box has many more options for species types. 


Both Lucky Tackle Box and Mystery Tackle Box have their pros and cons, but overall, these subscription services allow you to try the latest and best fishing accessories for your many sunny days on the water.